Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Pittsburgh Just Dodged the Amazon Bullet

We should be relieved that the tech giant opted not to move in.

Embed from Getty Images

Ever since Pittsburgh started popping up on lists of the nation’s most livable cities, locals have taken pride in that designation. Problems with the methodology of such rankings aside, Pittsburgh is a place where you don’t have to break the bank to afford rent. Where you can live in a single-family home with a back yard and still be at work Downtown in 20 minutes. Where most of us have enough money left in our pockets for a night out.

If Amazon had chosen Pittsburgh as the site of its second headquarters, all of that could’ve gone away.

The nationwide civic horse race to attract Amazon’s HQ2 has led to a tie, with both Queens and Arlington, Va., getting a massive influx of the company’s workers and business. Undoubtedly, there will be big changes in those areas — many of them positive. But others will strain the housing market and economic stability of those areas in a way that Pittsburgh will be happy to avoid.

Let’s start with rent. The sudden arrival of workers in the tens of thousands can only drive housing prices up; a New York Times report used Zillow data to estimate that rents in Pittsburgh would’ve increased an average of $96 per month were Amazon to have winded up here. (The same data suggests that, without Amazon, we’re actually due for decreasing rents in the coming years, so the net impact would be higher than $96). That’s not as big of a difference as some markets might’ve seen under Amazon, according to the same data, but more than enough to push lower-income residents into less desirable housing.

Such increases have the potential to snowball, as well. In Seattle, the site of Amazon’s original headquarters — a metro area only nominally more populous than Pittsburgh — a continued tech boom has led to rents similar to those found in Los Angeles and New York.

In San Francisco, where tech giants have driven the cost of living into the stratosphere, the differences are even more dramatic. The median rent for a one-bedroom apartment in San Francisco is $3,460 per month, according to Business Insider. The median cost of buying a home is more than $800,000. In other words, a place that would cost you $1,000 a month in Pittsburgh will cost three times that in San Francisco.

Rent isn’t the only expense that goes up in such cases, Business Insider adds — gas prices in San Francisco are more than 30 percent higher than the national average, the cost of a mid-range meal is double what you’d expect in most cities and even groceries are more expensive.

To be fair, wages have increased in Seattle and San Francisco, as well. But such increases in take-home pay can come at the expense of some civic control.

Noting the increased housing costs — and their inevitable byproduct, a rise in homelessness — Seattle earlier this year pushed for a per-employee tax levied on large corporations to fund housing initiatives and hopefully get people off the streets.

Amazon — a company notorious for paying nearly nothing in tax revenue — fought tooth and nail against the proposed tax, threatening to halt development in the city were it passed.

Despite the support of city council, the measure was not enacted.

That’s the kind of influence a gargantuan employer can have on a market. There’s no reason to believe that the climate would’ve been much different for Amazon in Pittsburgh, particularly after local leaders repeatedly refused to reveal the concessions they promised Amazon, despite court orders that they do so. (A statement released after Amazon’s HQ2 announcement promised that the pitches would finally be revealed in the coming days.)

Pittsburgh was willing to make sacrifices to woo Amazon before it got here; were we likely to get tough on the company down the line?

And yes — let’s talk traffic. Either Amazon would’ve moved into the booming tech area on the East End, which is virtually inaccessible by highway (leading to endless snarls throughout those dense neighborhoods), or it would’ve picked a more suburban campus.

You know what a suburban campus means?

Somebody’s going to have to go through a tunnel. And we’re ... not good at that.

There certainly would’ve been benefits to an Amazon headquarters in Pittsburgh. But it’s tough to imagine that it would be a net positive for all Pittsburghers; the data does not bear that theory out. We are already fortunate to have a growing tech community, expanding at a manageable rate for a market of our size.

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Edit Module Edit ModuleShow TagsEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

The Latest

Adda Coffee and Tea Expands to a Second Location

The coffee house brings its international focus and welcoming atmosphere to the North Side.

The 400-Word Review: Mortal Engines

Another attempt to start a dystopian franchise can't deliver on its strong premise.

Do You Know Uber's Top 10 Pittsburgh Destinations in 2018?

The rideshare company collects data on just about every aspect of the rider experience, including the most frequently visited locations.

Steelers’ Finishing Stretch Smells Like a Tomlin Referendum

In a season that remarkably could still go either way as Christmas approaches, we’re about to find out if Mike Tomlin still has the coaching chops that have allowed him to succeed at such a high level for so long.

The 400-Word Review: The Favourite

The quirky period drama starring Emma Stone is one of the year's best films.

My Favorite Room with Heather Abraham

Each issue, HOME goes inside the room of one of our favorite Pittsburghers.

Look Inside a Home That's a True Gateway to Pittsburgh

After 50 years away, Dick and Vicki Mallary returned to Pittsburgh and spent years painstakingly remodeling a condo in the heart of Downtown.

This Old Pittsburgh House: A Ghost in the Library

It's said that the mischievous spirit of Amanda Bayne Balph still haunts the red brick Victorian home in Bellevue.

“Trocking” Along: Living the Art-Filled Life in Pittsburgh

Patricia Sheahan’s home in the Brewhouse Art Lofts on the South side doubles as a gallery space showcasing her collection of art, antique finds and roadside treasures.

Down to Earth is the Hottest Trend at High Point Market

Get the scoop on the furnishing and decor trends to come out of the influential High Point Market trade show, including a return to natural materials.

Winter 2019: Things We Love

Here are the local gems worth obsessing over.

The Best New Restaurants in Pittsburgh in 2018

Our dining critic picks the eight top openings of 2018 and suggests one more to keep an eye on.

A Guide to Under-21 College Nightlife in Pittsburgh

Guest blogger Sarah Connor helps college kids head out at night, whatever their birth year.

The 400-Word Review: Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

The animated wing of Spider-Man's movie world proves to be a groundbreaking step in animation.

New Venue To Serve as Downtown's Home for Magic

The intimate venue will offer close-up, "parlour" magic shows for small audiences beginning in February.